The most important thing is that Oliver likes it, right? 🙂

We swore we would avoid the myriad of big, ugly, plastic contraptions that tend to clutter the home of the newly-babied, but reality has set in: This baby wants to be upright and he wants to be entertained — constantly. I had (perhaps naive) visions of puttering about the apartment while Oliver slept blissfully in the Ergo carrier, but A) he doesn’t like it enough to spend considerable amounts of time in it (he’ll almost never sleep it); and B) I still have to put him down somewhere in order to shower, use the washroom, fold laundry or cook hot food.

Enter the Big. Ugly. Plastic.

Somehow, in a household averse to cheap eyesores of clutter, we now find ourselves the not-so-proud owners of a play gym, a Bumbo seat, a swing and an exersaucer. How ever did this happen?!

It started innocently enough, when Oliver was about six weeks old and began to show interest in batting and/or kicking at toys that were dangled above him. I bought a small clip-on toy arch to attach to his stroller and bassinet, and he loved it. We started using it at playtime (holding it above him while he lay on a towel on the floor), and I suddenly realized that if we had a device with a free-standing toy arch (i.e. a play gym), I could probably buy myself just enough time to prepare my breakfast in the morning.

And so it was that I searched on Craigslist until I found this mat, in nearly new condition, for only $20 (it still had the $99.95 price tag on the packaging!). The mat has admittedly been a huge success, buying me anywhere from five to 25 minutes of Oliver Entertainment. It has adapted well to his ongoing development, and I anticipate that he will continue to use it in the months to come. It also stores flat so it can be tucked out of the way, thus minimizing the proliferation of ugly clutter. I give the mat an ‘A’ for its entertainment value, although I’m still not sure that I’d have wanted to shell out $100 for a so-called “musical” toy that plays only four-bar snippets of the same three nursery rhyme songs over and over again. We’ll probably hang on to this for the next kid, since it’s been so useful and is in such good condition.

When Oliver hit two months old, he began to be frustrated with being flat on his back all the time. I swapped the stroller bassinet for the toddler seat, and our daily walks became a time of enjoyment and discovery. I knew that he would also want to be more upright at home, so I started looking for a seat of some sort. We somehow came to the conclusion that a swing would provide more entertainment than a bouncer/lounger seat (I think we had visions of him sleeping in it for hours at a time, à la Happiest Baby on the Block), so I set out to find a gently used swing, with the caveat that it must be able to run on power; not just batteries. We soon became not-so-proud owners of a very well kept one of these. The swing has been of limited use, and it’s clunky and cheaply made. Our child will not sleep in it, nor will he while away an afternoon staring intently at the colourful mobile. At first, he’d happily swing for as long as a half hour, but now it buys me at most 10 minutes, and that’s only if he also has toys in hand. In retrospect, I think a vibrating bouncer seat would have been just as effective, with the added bonuses of a much smaller footprint, greater portability and a built-in toy arch. We will be re-selling the swing (hopefully for what we paid for it) as soon as Oliver outgrows it.

The Bumbo seat was a natural extension of the “something to help him sit more upright” thought process, and was the only item I actually purchased before Oliver was born. I happened to find a secondhand one in the “coveted” lime green colour, and I’d heard that a lot of kids love them during the three to six months pre-sitting stage. Oliver, it turns out, is one of the kids who doesn’t. Even though we only ever use the seat while we are directly supervising and interacting with him, he will sit in it for just a few short minutes before he arches his back and begins to fuss. I was hoping to use the Bumbo and tray as a pseudo-high chair (before we buy the real thing), but I guess it is not to be. The verdict: we’ll keep it for now, as sometimes it’s nice to be able to have him sitting up and facing us when we play — even if only for a few minutes — but I suspect we’ll be re-selling the Bumbo once his pudgy thighs outgrow it. If we decide we want one for the next kid, they are easy enough to come by.

Finally, the exersaucer — the Biggest. Ugliest. Plastic-est thing of all — and the one thing we swore we would never buy. But then Oliver hit four months old and wanted not only to be upright, but to be able to easily explore (i.e. grab, manipulate and chew) the things around him. And I still needed a way to entertain him while I showered and cooked. So we caved and bought one of these. I found the absolute cheapest used (but functional) one I could, and spent an hour sanitizing all the surfaces and toys. It is hideous, cumbersome, cheaply-made, clunks loudly when it bounces, and comes equipped with the most incredibly obnoxious collection of sounds, songs and phrases; but lo and behold, Oliver loves it. The first time I put him in there, he hooted excitedly and grabbed at everything within his reach. He is able to rotate himself around to play with the various activity toys, all of which are developmentally appropriate for him at this time (i.e. he is able to use them as intended). So for Oliver, this toy is a win; however, J and I despise it and cannot wait until he outgrows it. I might even consider giving this one away for free, just to get it out of our home :). I’m really glad that we bought it secondhand so that we don’t feel compelled to hang on to it for the next kid.

The next thing on our list is a highchair, and I cannot bring myself to buy yet another Big. Ugly. Plastic. Thing. Unfortunately, the higher quality and more aesthetically pleasing alternatives (such as this lovely wooden chair) are prohibitively expensive, and very difficult to come by secondhand. We want a chair that can bring Oliver right up to the table (no plastic tray), as we feel that is better aligned with the baby-led weaning philosophy. It’s looking more and more like the solution might be found at good old Ikea, but we really need to have a look at the chairs in person before making a decision.

Which highchair do you use, and would you recommend it?

20 responses to “BIG. UGLY. PLASTIC.

  1. We had a giant ugly plastic sit-in-it thing that Melissa very kindly (and with a huge sigh of relief!) gave us when A was little…. it was HIDEOUS and it was known as “the pleasure palace”. Pretty much exactly like the one you linked too. Totally grim, but fantastically useful. A LOVED it, and E would pop into it at any opportunity too (aged 3?!). Eventually we passed it on to someone who also developed a facial tic as soon as she saw it (design conscious architect…!), but who recognized the potential to PEE by herself. Oh joy, etc.

    Yes, they are foul, but these valuable quiet moments are so FANTASTIC, it’s worth the temporary presence of ugly plastic.

    Re: the highchairs, we have 2 Stokke Tripp Trapps (one for each of the children) that they are still using. Quite expensive, but overall v good value for money, plus I think they look quite nice. Would imagine they have decent re-sale value as well. They tuck under a table quiet well too (wasn’t sure the one you linked to tucked under neatly). If you are lucky enough to get a second hand one, you can always re-paint to smarten them up/match the decor….!

    • I love the Tripp Trapp, but they are just so frightfully expensive here. The chair alone is more than $350 with tax, and the baby seat attachment (which I don’t think we could forego at this age) adds almost another $100. And then there’s the seat cushion…

      If I could find a decent secondhand one on Craigslist, with baby seat included, we’d buy it for sure!

      It’s nice to hear that your kids are still using them beyond the high chair phase. I always wondered whether these products designed to “grow with the child” ever really end up having a life beyond their original intended use.

  2. We haven’t used it yet, but we bought one of the fisher price space saver ones. They just strap on to your existing chairs, so you can definitely use it at the table for family dinners. Our dining table is really tall, so any “normal” high chair would not have been high enough to work, so space saver it was. If we had a normal table I would have sprung for the Tripp Trapp. I like that they can use it as a normal chair later. I think the website has a similar one for less.

    • This chair gets so many amazing reviews as a high chair, but a lot of complaints as a booster seat because it doesn’t tuck under most dining tables very well, due to the arms (you probably don’t have this problem because your table is tall). I wonder if it would work with our table?

  3. My friends have a nylon portable booster seat that straps onto a regular chair. Puts their little girl right up to the table. They love it and take it everywhere. I tried to find a link, but I could only find these things that drape over the back of the chair.
    I will see if I can find out the name of their seat.

  4. Hurrah! It’s the pleasure palace! He looks delighted in it.
    Re highchair – I’d go for the IKEA Antelop with a tray when he is small and move him into a tripp trapp when he is a little bigger and it will last for years… well that is my opinion after 4 babies and I don’t know how many highchairs! I seem to remember one particularly large plastic monstrosity being eaten by a mouse in the attic between babies 2 and 3….

    • Apparently recommendations from sisters carry enough weight to convince J of the merits of a $400+ high chair 🙂

      I’m also looking at this one here: which is appealing because the baby seat part of it detaches from the main chair and can be used in restaurants and other peoples’ homes. Someone has one on Craigslist for < $200 (including both the base and the baby seat), which is a pretty good deal.

      • Haha! I think the Tripp Trapp is available for less on, don’t know if they will ship to Canada? My only comment on the one you linked to above is that it looks as thought the seat height is fixed, thus less use to be gained from it in the future, The t t allows for adjusting the seat level and the feet level, hence its use for a longer time…..

        As M says, you could go for the IKEA Antelop to start with, then move on to the t t (without the expense of the baby kit, which I had and was a bit of a pain). Also easier to hose down in those early messy days!

        • I finally found a Tripp Trapp on Craigslist!

          I noticed the same thing about the Handysitt, and when I e-mailed the woman who was selling it, she confirmed that there is no height adjustment for the seat. I’m not entirely convinced any seat could really fit a child *well* from six months to five years without being adjustable…

  5. Well when you decide to get rid of the big.ugly.plastic. circle of relief I will gladly take it off your hands as we will need one in the future. I do have one of those chairs that hook on to the table which you may try if you like. It might work well on the sailboat or camping. We received it as a gift but it would not fit either of our tables.

    • Ahhhhh! Congratulations!! 🙂 When are you due?

      Which high chair do you have? We’ve been looking at the Phil & Ted’s MeToo, the Phil & Ted’s Lobster and the Inglesina Fast Table as options for restaurants/travel/etc.

      • Due in mid-June, will find out in a couple of weeks if Bug Jr. is boy or a girl. The chair we got as a gift is a Guzzie and Gus but I can’t find it listed anywhere to reference. It’s like the rest but the under table hooks are much longer than any of the ones you referenced. I’d have to take a picture and email it to J at work.

  6. So far I have found that the more annoying and/or stupid you think a toy is, the more they love it. This applies through 2 1/2 as well, and includes books and movies.

    One thing nice about a stand alone high chair is that if you want them in the kitchen with you while you cook, or wherever in the house, you can stick toys and/or snacks on the tray and they sit there watching you at your level. If it has the wheels, you can even change rooms with them in it easily.

    • It’s true! We swore we wouldn’t buy any battery-operated sound and lights type toys, but we’ve gotten a number of them as gifts… and unsurprisingly, Oliver just loves them 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s